top of page

Tasty Talk: Justify the Contract SP 3/3

HELLO Ball Boys and Ball Girls. It's time for Tasty Talk.

Recently, Twenty-seven years of labor peace have ended for MLB. Meaning we have a long cold winter ahead of us. Nearly $1.7 billion was committed to free agents during November, smashing the prior record by 4x. Meaning, it's time for us to play "Justify the Contact."

Dan-o's season has some INCREDIBLY RIDICULOUS DEALS through Christmas that include: $1 Koozie add-on at checkout, Gift Cards at $50 or more at 40% off. (Example $50 gift card for $30). For a couple of days only this week, 12/10-12/10 FREE shipping on all three variety packs. Lastly, 12/12-12/19 FREE mystery hat with a 20oz variety pack purchase.

For part one of Justify that Contact, click here. For part two, click here

Now, let's jump into Justify that Contact for the SP signed pre-lockout. We will ignore recency bias as most MLB teams don't but look at a few metrics: Age, career WAR, career ERA/FIP, career W-L%, career 162 game average IP.

-Michael Wacha 1yr/$8mil- Bos

The former first-round pick of the Cardinals has suffered injury upon injury over the last four seasons, which has led him to bounce between 1-year deals in the AL East. At 30yo, a career 6.8WAR, with a 4.14ERA/4.07FIP, a career .568W-L% to go with a healthy season average of 182IP. The Redsox might luck into a solid #3. I'm going to Justify the Contract.

-Corey Kluber 1yr/$8mil- TB

The 10yr, 2x Cy Young, 3x All-Star finds himself on another 1 yr prove deal. At 35yo the asking price isn't too steep. I will say this is a solid deal after barely pitching for two seasons and making 16starts. We know the track record; Tampa is excellent for these deals. I am all for it. JUSTIFIED!

-Michael Lorenzen 1yr/$7mil- LAA

The fire burns HOT with Lorenzen and has been for his entire career. I love this deal because if any of these 1yr deals turn into the true proved it contract extension; it's this one. $7mil paid by the Angels to a guy who is out to prove EVERYONE wrong that he can be an SP. The Angels already have one excellent two-way player, and maybe Lorenzen takes a page from his book and learns. For those reasons alone, JUSTIFIED!

-Jordan Lyles 1yr/$7mil- Bal

I don't get it. $7mil for a guy with a career -2.5WAR, coming off a season where he posted a 5.15ERA in 32 appearances. The health was there, excellent. No one wants to play in Baltimore, so they are taking a flier on the 30yo with a career .406W-L% and 5.21ERA/4.72FIP. NOT JUSTIFIED!

-James Paxton 1yr/$6mil- Bos

Coming off another injury, big maple's reunion in Seattle did not go as planned. The now 33yo is just looking to keep the dream alive. A solid career 12.8WAR says he has done it and can be a winner. Paxton hasn't pitched in two seasons nearly, and at 33, the outlook isn't promising. The career .633W-L%, 3.59ERA/3.31FIP is all there for Paxton. The deal is a STEAL for the RedSox if he can get on the mound for 25+ starts. Also, counting in that he played for the Yankees and has experience with the AL East.

-Rich Hill 1yr/$5mil- Bos

Seventeen seasons, 41yo, and still making money and getting it done. He still made 30+ starts in 2021 at 40yo. I am a fan of the move here to Boston. The career .587W-L%, 3.80ERA/3.99FIP, and stability of 150IP in a season is all Boston needs from Hill to eat innings and take the Hill. Justified!

-Dylan Bundy 1yr/$4mil- Min

Yes another team, that not many guys want to play for because of the recent track record. Bundy is taking a prove-it deal to prove that the health is back and that he can make it through a season at 29yo. Through seven seasons, he owns a .447W-L%, 4.72ERA/4.69FIP, and 178IP if he can remain healthy. It should be enough for the contract, but they could have done better. NOT JUSTIFIED.

-Jose Quintana 1yr/$2mil- Pit

At 32, this is a desperate move that he hopes he gets a rotation role. That leads him to hope to prove enough value to land him on a contender—the career 23.7WAR is the best on this list. Quintana proved he can stay healthy in 2021 and still play. The Pirates needed a veteran in the rotation, and Quintana average 196IP in a season with a .509W-L% and 3.84ERA/3.68FIP. I think this will be a sneaky good move that lands Quintana on a contender at the deadline. JUSTIFIED!

Still Available worth noting:

Tyler Anderson, Matthew Boyd, Trevor Cahill, Zach Davies, Danny Duffy, Mike Fiers, Mike Foltynewicz, Zack Greinke, Clayton Kershaw, Yusei Kikuchi, Kwang-Hyun Kim, Wade LeBlanc, Michael Pineda, Carlos Rodon, Drew Smyly, Hyeon-Jong Yang.

Others available:

Brett Anderson, Chris Archer, Jake Arrieta, Johnny Cueto, JA Happ, Matt Harvey, Jakob Junis, John Lester, Martin Perez, Vince Velasquez.

Thanks for reading!

21 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All
bottom of page